The Short Version
- Find out what you have. Bullion coin, common pre-1933 gold, or a scarce collector coin? Each is priced differently.
- Do the math yourself before anyone makes an offer: gold content × spot price.
- Get several quotes from appropriate buyers, on the same day, for the same coins.
- Watch for lowball tactics and be ready to walk away.
- Get paid safely and keep records for taxes.
The biggest losses usually don’t come from a dealer shaving a few percent off a bullion coin. They come from selling a valuable collector coin as if it were scrap gold.
Step 1: Identify What You Have
Sort your coins into three groups:
- Modern bullion coins: American Gold Eagles and Buffalos, Maple Leafs, Krugerrands, Philharmonics, Britannias and similar coins. These are priced from spot, and most dealers quote them easily.
- Common pre-1933 US gold and older foreign gold: common-date $20, $10 and $5 US coins, British sovereigns, French 20 francs and the like. These usually trade at a premium over melt, sometimes a significant one.
- Scarce and collector coins: better dates, rare mint marks, high grades, early US gold, certified coins with strong grades, and commemoratives. These are priced on collector value, which can be far above melt.
Our guide to bullion vs numismatic coins explains the difference. For US gold, check the date and mint mark against a price guide before you show anyone. Rarities like the 1927-D double eagle are extreme examples, but many less famous dates are worth well above common ones. For specific denominations, see what is a Double Eagle coin?, how much is a 2.5 dollar gold coin worth? and did they make a gold dollar coin?
Don’t clean your coins. Cleaning can wipe out collector value and won’t raise a bullion price. Sell them as they are.
Step 2: Work Out Your Own Numbers
Before you ask for a quote, calculate:
Melt value = pure gold content (troy oz) × current gold spot price
Common gold contents:
| Coin | Pure gold |
|---|---|
| 1 oz Gold Eagle, Buffalo, Maple Leaf, Krugerrand | 1.0000 troy oz |
| US $20 double eagle | 0.9675 troy oz |
| US $10 eagle | 0.48375 troy oz |
| US $5 half eagle | 0.24187 troy oz |
| US $2.50 quarter eagle | 0.12094 troy oz |
| 1/10 oz Gold Eagle | 0.1000 troy oz |
See our US gold coin weights for more. Then set rough expectations:
- Popular 1 oz bullion coins: a competitive dealer bid is often close to melt, and sometimes slightly above for popular coins in strong demand.
- Fractional bullion coins: bids are often a bit lower as a percentage of melt than for 1 oz coins. See fractional gold coins.
- Common pre-1933 gold: usually at or above melt, depending on type and condition.
- Collector coins: check recent auction results and price guides for the exact coin and grade. Dealers buy below retail, but they shouldn’t be paying melt for a coin that sells well above it.
Bid and ask, and why dealers pay less than they charge, are explained in spot price vs premium.
Step 3: Choose Where to Sell
| Buyer | Best for | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|
| Established local coin shop | Bullion and common gold; quick, in-person payment | Offers vary a lot between shops; get more than one |
| Major online bullion dealer | Bullion in larger quantities; posted buy prices | Shipping risk and timing; price locked at a set moment |
| Auction house | Scarce and high-value collector coins | Seller’s fees; weeks or months before payment |
| Coin shows | Comparing many dealers in one place | Bring your own numbers; offers can be rushed |
| Private sale or online marketplace | Possibly higher prices for collector coins | Scams, chargebacks, fees and effort |
| Pawn shops, jewelers, “cash for gold” buyers | Speed | Often pay scrap rates, ignoring collector value |
For bullion, coin shops and online dealers usually give the best combination of price and convenience. For anything that might be rare, get a specialist’s opinion, or an auction house’s estimate, before accepting a dealer offer.
Consider certification first if you have an uncertified coin that may be valuable. Grading by PCGS or NGC costs money and takes time, but for a scarce coin it can make a large difference in what buyers will pay.
Step 4: Get Several Quotes, the Right Way
- Same day, same coins. Spot moves throughout the day, so compare offers made close together.
- Ask how the offer is calculated: “What are you paying per ounce?” or “What percentage of spot is that?” A good dealer will tell you.
- Ask about coins individually. Insist on separate prices for anything that might be a better date, not a single bulk number for the lot.
- Get it in writing. A written or emailed quote is easier to compare and harder to change.
- Don’t reveal your lowest acceptable price. Let the buyer make the first offer.
- Mention you’re comparing offers. Many dealers improve their bid when they know you’re shopping around.
Red Flags and Common Lowball Tactics
- “It’s all just melt.” True for bullion, but not for scarce dates. If you’ve identified a better date, ask why they’re paying melt.
- “Your coin is cleaned” or “Your coin is fake.” Sometimes true, and sometimes a pressure tactic. Get a second opinion before you accept a lower price on that basis.
- Weighing everything together as scrap. Coins should be identified and priced individually, not tossed on a scale.
- Scales you can’t see. Ask to see the reading. Your own accurate scale at home helps.
- Pressure to decide now. A fair offer will usually still stand after you’ve checked elsewhere, adjusted for any change in spot.
- Traveling buyers, hotel-room events, “gold parties” and mail-in envelopes. These often pay far below market. By the time you realize, the buyer may be gone.
Getting Paid Safely
- In person: cash, a business check or a wire. For large sums, a wire or check from a known business may be safer than carrying cash.
- Shipping to a dealer: use the dealer’s insured shipping instructions or fully insured, tracked shipping. Lock your price before shipping and get the quote confirmed in writing.
- Selling privately: get paid in full, with funds cleared, before handing over or shipping coins. Be very cautious with payment methods that can be reversed, and with personal checks from strangers.
- Bring ID. Reputable dealers in the US usually need identification for purchases, and some states require it.
Taxes and Paperwork
In the United States:
- Collectibles tax. The IRS generally treats gold coins and bullion as collectibles. Long-term gains on collectibles can be taxed at a higher maximum rate (28%) than many other long-term capital gains. Short-term gains are taxed as ordinary income.
- Keep your purchase records. Your cost basis determines your gain. If you inherited coins, the basis is generally the value at the date of death, which is worth documenting.
- Dealer reporting. Dealers must file reports for some sales of certain coins in certain quantities. Other popular coins, including American Gold Eagles, are generally not reportable. Whether a report is filed doesn’t change whether tax is owed.
Tax rules change and depend on your situation, and other countries’ rules differ. Talk to a tax professional before a large sale.
Frequently Asked Questions
What’s the best place to sell gold coins?
For bullion, a competitive local coin shop or an established online dealer usually gives a fair price quickly. For scarce or high-value coins, an auction house or a dealer who specializes in that series often gets more. Pawn shops and jewelers usually pay the least.
How much below spot do dealers pay for gold coins?
For popular 1 oz bullion coins, a competitive bid is often close to spot, sometimes slightly above for coins in high demand. Smaller coins and less popular products may get a bit less. If an offer is well below melt for a common bullion coin, get other quotes.
Should I sell gold coins all at once?
There’s no single right answer. Selling in stages spreads out your exposure to price swings and may help with tax planning. Selling at once is simpler. Don’t time your sale around predictions you can’t verify.
Is a Gold Eagle easier to sell than a Buffalo?
Both are easy to sell to US dealers. The Eagle is traded slightly more widely. See American Gold Eagle vs Gold Buffalo.