Bullion and Gold Coins

Proof and Piedfort Coins: What the Terms Mean for Collectors

What proof and piedfort coins are, how they're made, whether silver proofs are real silver, plus privy marks, royals and whether either is worth collecting.

On this page
  1. Proof and Piedfort at a Glance
  2. What Is a Proof Coin?
  3. Types of Proof Finish
  4. Is a Silver Proof Coin Real Silver?
  5. What Is a Piedfort Coin?
  6. Related Terms: Privy Marks and Royals
  7. Are Proofs and Piedforts Worth Collecting?
  8. Handling and Storing Proofs
  9. Frequently Asked Questions

Proof and Piedfort at a Glance

  • A proof coin is struck with specially prepared dies and blanks, usually more than once, to give sharp detail and, on most modern proofs, mirror-like backgrounds. “Proof” describes how the coin was made, not its condition.
  • A piedfort coin is struck on a blank that’s thicker and heavier than normal, usually about twice the standard thickness. Most modern piedforts are also proofs.

Both are collector products, so they sell for more than the same design in regular or bullion form.

What Is a Proof Coin?

Proofs began as test strikes and presentation pieces: coins made carefully to show off a design or check new dies. The US Mint has sold proofs to collectors since the 1800s, and most modern mints now offer proof versions of their circulating and bullion coins.

What makes a modern proof different:

  • Polished dies. The background areas of the dies (the fields) are polished to a mirror finish. On “cameo” proofs, the raised design is given a frosted texture, so it stands out against the mirror.
  • Prepared blanks. Blanks are cleaned and polished before striking.
  • Multiple strikes. Proofs are usually struck at least twice, at slower speeds, to bring up fine detail.
  • Careful handling. Coins are handled individually and sealed in capsules, often with a box and certificate.

Because proof describes the method of manufacture, a proof coin is graded on a separate scale, written PF or PR, from 60 to 70. A proof that’s been mishandled can grade low (a scuffed PF62, for example), but it’s still a proof.

Types of Proof Finish

Finish What it looks like Example
Standard (cameo) proof Mirror fields, frosted design Annual proof American Silver Eagle
Deep or ultra cameo Strong contrast between mirror and frost Grading designation (PCGS “DCAM”, NGC “Ultra Cameo”)
Reverse proof Frosted fields, mirror design 2006-P and 2011-P reverse proof Silver Eagles
Enhanced reverse proof Several finishes on one coin 2019-S Enhanced Reverse Proof Silver Eagle
Matte or satin proof Fine-grained, non-reflective surface Some early 20th century US gold proofs

Burnished uncirculated coins, like the W-mint-mark Silver Eagles, are a different collector finish: satin rather than mirror, struck on treated blanks. Our Silver Eagle values chart shows how proof, reverse proof and burnished versions of the same year compare.

Is a Silver Proof Coin Real Silver?

A silver proof coin contains the silver its issuer states. A proof American Silver Eagle holds one troy ounce of .999 fine silver, the same as the bullion coin.

The confusion comes from proof sets that include both base-metal and silver versions:

  • US proof sets before 1965 contain 90% silver dimes, quarters and half dollars, because those circulating coins were 90% silver at the time.
  • US “Silver Proof” sets from 1992 to 2018 use 90% silver for the dime, quarter and half dollar.
  • Silver Proof sets from 2019 onward use .999 fine silver for those coins.
  • Standard (clad) proof sets from 1968 onward contain copper-nickel clad coins with no silver, even though they look just as shiny.

Check the set’s packaging or a catalog. Silver and clad proofs of the same year can look almost identical, but the silver set will say “Silver” on the box and carries a higher price.

What Is a Piedfort Coin?

“Piedfort” (sometimes spelled piefort) comes from French and roughly means “heavy measure”. A piedfort is a coin struck on an unusually thick blank, typically double the normal thickness and weight, using the regular dies. The face looks the same as the standard coin. The difference shows in the edge and the heft.

History. Piedforts go back to medieval France and England. Historians aren’t certain what they were originally for. The leading suggestions are that they were presentation pieces for officials or patrons, reference pieces showing mint workers the approved design, or trial strikes. Whatever their purpose, they weren’t made for circulation.

Modern piedforts. Several mints revived the format as a collector product, among them the Royal Mint in the UK and the Monnaie de Paris. They’re usually struck in sterling or fine silver with a proof finish, often in limited editions. A typical example is a silver piedfort version of a commemorative £2 coin, which holds roughly twice the silver of the standard silver proof.

Privy mark. A small extra symbol added to a coin’s design. Historically, privy marks identified the mint, the moneyer or the time period of a striking. Today they mostly mark special editions or anniversaries. Examples include the “V75” mark on the 2020-W Silver Eagle proof and the many privy marks on Perth Mint and Royal Mint bullion coins. A privy-marked coin is a separate collector issue and may have a much smaller mintage than the regular coin.

Royal. In collecting, “royal” most often refers to a special type of Spanish colonial coin. Ordinary colonial “cob” coins were crudely made, irregular lumps of silver or gold. Royals (sometimes called galanos) were carefully struck, fully round versions of those coins. Like piedforts, they’re thought to have been presentation pieces, possibly made to show the king. Genuine royals are rare and expensive. People also sometimes use “royal coin” loosely for coins issued by a monarchy or by the Royal Mint, so check the context.

Are Proofs and Piedforts Worth Collecting?

They can be rewarding to collect. Proofs show a coin’s design at its sharpest, and piedforts are satisfying, substantial pieces, often with small mintages. A few modern issues have risen in value, mainly limited editions that sold out quickly.

The financial picture deserves caution:

  • You pay well above metal value. A proof or piedfort usually sells at a large premium over its silver or gold content.
  • Resale is often lower than the issue price. Many modern proofs and piedforts resell for less than buyers paid the mint, sometimes close to metal value. “Limited edition” doesn’t guarantee demand.
  • Condition is everything. A fingerprint, hairline or spot on a mirror surface can cut a proof’s value noticeably.

If your main goal is owning metal, bullion strikes are the cheaper route. Our article on whether to buy proof or uncirculated coins compares the two for different goals, and bullion vs numismatic coins explains why collector premiums behave so differently from bullion premiums.

Handling and Storing Proofs

  • Never touch the faces of a proof. Hold it by the edge, ideally with cotton or nitrile gloves.
  • Leave it in its original capsule. Opening capsules invites hairlines and spots.
  • Don’t clean a proof. Even gentle wiping leaves hairlines that show up clearly under a light.
  • Store it somewhere cool and dry. Silver proofs can develop white spots; see our guide to milk spots on silver bullion coins.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are proof coins?

Proof coins are coins struck specially for collectors, using polished dies and prepared blanks and usually several strikes, to produce sharp detail and mirror-like fields. They’re sold in protective packaging rather than released into circulation.

Which is better, mint state or proof?

Neither is better in general. Mint state coins are regular strikes that never circulated. Proofs are a special manufacturing process. Collectors choose between them by taste and by which set they’re building. For buying precious metal at the lowest cost, regular uncirculated bullion coins are usually better value.

What does piedfort mean?

It’s a French term, roughly “heavy measure”, for a coin struck on a blank about twice the normal thickness and weight.

How much silver can I legally own?

In the United States, there’s no general limit on how much silver an individual can own. Some dealer transactions have reporting requirements, and other countries have their own rules.

The complete guide to bullion and gold coins

Bullion Coins: Definition and How They Differ from Numismatic Coins
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →