The Quick Verdict
The American Gold Eagle and American Gold Buffalo are both US Mint bullion coins, and the 1 oz size of each contains exactly one troy ounce of pure gold with a $50 face value. The main differences:
- Purity: the Eagle is 22 karat (.9167 fine), alloyed with silver and copper. The Buffalo is 24 karat (.9999 fine).
- Sizes: the Eagle comes in 1 oz, 1/2 oz, 1/4 oz and 1/10 oz. The Buffalo is essentially 1 oz only.
- Durability: the Eagle’s alloy is harder. The Buffalo’s pure gold scratches and dents more easily.
- Price: premiums are often similar, with the Buffalo sometimes a little higher. It varies by dealer and market.
If you want fractional sizes or the most widely traded US gold coin, the Eagle is the natural choice. If you prefer pure 24-karat gold or the classic Buffalo design, the Buffalo is a fine choice. For pure metal exposure, either works. Compare the delivered price per ounce on the day you buy.
Specifications Side by Side
| American Gold Eagle (1 oz) | American Gold Buffalo (1 oz) | |
|---|---|---|
| First issued | 1986 | 2006 |
| Fineness | .9167 (22 karat) | .9999 (24 karat) |
| Alloy | Gold with silver and copper | Pure gold |
| Pure gold | 1.0000 troy oz | 1.0000 troy oz |
| Gross weight | 33.931 g | 31.108 g |
| Diameter | 32.7 mm | 32.7 mm |
| Face value | $50 | $50 |
| Sizes | 1, 1/2, 1/4, 1/10 oz | 1 oz (fractions only in 2008) |
| Obverse | Saint-Gaudens’ striding Liberty | Fraser’s Native American portrait |
| Reverse | Eagle family (1986–2021); eagle head (2021 on) | American bison |
Purity: Does 22 Karat Mean Less Gold?
No. This is the most common misunderstanding. A 1 oz Gold Eagle is made slightly heavier than an ounce so that, after adding silver and copper, it still contains a full troy ounce of pure gold. The extra metal adds weight and hardness, not gold.
So when comparing prices, a 1 oz Eagle and a 1 oz Buffalo represent the same amount of gold. A dealer pays for the gold content, not the gross weight.
Purity can matter for personal preference, and in some international markets buyers favor .9999 gold. In the US, both coins are easily recognized.
Durability and Handling
Pure gold is soft. A Buffalo can pick up scratches, dings and rim bumps from handling, from coins knocking together in a tube, or from a careless drop. The 22-karat Eagle is noticeably more resistant to wear. That’s one reason gold was traditionally alloyed for coinage, as with the 90% gold of historic US coins like the double eagle.
For bullion, light marks usually have little effect on what a dealer pays. For proofs or coins you hope to sell at a collector premium, they matter more. Handle Buffalos by the edges and keep them in capsules or their original packaging.
Sizes
- Gold Eagle: 1 oz ($50), 1/2 oz ($25), 1/4 oz ($10) and 1/10 oz ($5), made every year.
- Gold Buffalo: 1 oz in nearly every year. In 2008 only, the Mint also made 1/2, 1/4 and 1/10 oz Buffalos, in limited numbers. Those 2008 fractionals are now collector coins priced well above their gold value.
If you want to buy in smaller amounts, the Eagle is the practical US option. Fractions carry higher premiums per ounce; see our guide to fractional gold coins.
Design and History
Gold Eagle. Authorized by the Gold Bullion Coin Act of 1985 and first sold in 1986. The obverse adapts Augustus Saint-Gaudens’ Liberty from the 1907 double eagle. From 1986 to 2021, the reverse showed a family of eagles at a nest, designed by Miley Busiek. In 2021 the Mint introduced a new reverse with a close-up eagle head, designed by Jennie Norris. Dates from 1986 to 1991 are in Roman numerals.
Gold Buffalo. Authorized by the Presidential $1 Coin Act of 2005 and first issued in 2006, it was the US Mint’s first 24-karat gold coin for the public. Its design comes from James Earle Fraser’s 1913 Buffalo nickel: a Native American portrait on the obverse and an American bison on the reverse.
Both coins also come in proof versions, and both have had burnished uncirculated collector versions with a “W” mint mark, priced well above bullion. See is it better to buy proof or uncirculated coins? for how those compare.
Premiums and Resale
Both coins usually sell at a premium over spot. Which is cheaper on a given day depends on supply and on the dealer. In many markets the Eagle is slightly cheaper and more heavily traded, while the Buffalo is sometimes a little higher. Treat that as a tendency, not a rule.
When selling, both are widely accepted by US dealers. The Eagle’s long history, large mintages and range of sizes give it a slight edge in liquidity, but in practice both sell easily.
To compare fairly, look at the total delivered cost per ounce of gold, including payment fees and shipping. Our guide to spot price vs premium shows how. Also ask what the dealer would pay you today for each coin: a low purchase premium matters less than a strong buyback.
IRA Eligibility
Both coins are generally accepted in self-directed precious metals IRAs. US tax law specifically allows American Gold Eagles, despite their 22-karat fineness. Buffalos qualify because they exceed the minimum purity standard for gold bullion. IRA metals must be held by an approved custodian or depository, not at home.
Custodians set their own product lists and fees, and rules change, so confirm with your custodian and a tax professional before buying for a retirement account. Be wary of sellers who push expensive proof or collector coins for IRAs; their high premiums are rarely recovered.
Which Should You Buy?
| If you… | Consider |
|---|---|
| Want fractional sizes | Gold Eagle |
| Want the most widely traded US gold coin | Gold Eagle |
| Worry about scratches and handling | Gold Eagle |
| Prefer pure 24-karat gold | Gold Buffalo |
| Like the classic Buffalo nickel design | Gold Buffalo |
| Just want the cheapest ounce of US gold today | Whichever has the lower delivered price per ounce |
There’s no wrong answer between the two. Many buyers hold both. Neither coin is guaranteed to rise in value; gold prices can fall as well as rise.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the Gold Buffalo worth more than the Gold Eagle?
Not in gold content: both 1 oz coins hold exactly one troy ounce. The Buffalo sometimes sells at a slightly higher premium, but that’s down to supply and demand, not extra gold.
Why does the Gold Eagle weigh more than an ounce?
Because it’s 22 karat. The added silver and copper bring the total weight to 33.931 g while keeping the pure gold content at 1 troy oz. See our US gold coin weights guide for how alloyed gold coins are measured.
Which is easier to sell?
Both are easy to sell to US dealers. The Eagle is traded slightly more widely. Our guide to selling gold coins without getting lowballed covers getting a fair price for either.
Are Gold Eagles and Buffalos bullion or collector coins?
The regular versions are bullion, priced on gold content. Proofs, burnished coins and the 2008 fractional Buffalos are collector issues. See bullion vs numismatic coins.