What Silver War Nickels Are
Silver war nickels are Jefferson nickels struck from late 1942 through 1945 in a special wartime alloy:
| Metal | Share |
|---|---|
| Copper | 56% |
| Silver | 35% |
| Manganese | 9% |
Each coin weighs 5.00 grams and contains about 1.75 grams (0.05626 troy ounces) of pure silver. They’re the only US five-cent coins ever made with silver for circulation. Because even worn examples hold real silver, they’re collected both as historical coins and as a small form of “junk silver.”
Why the Mint Made Them
Nickel was a critical war material in World War II, used in armor plate and other military alloys. To save it, Congress authorized a change in the five-cent coin’s composition in 1942. The Mint tested several alternatives before settling on the copper-silver-manganese alloy, which worked in vending machines and could be struck on existing equipment.
To make the new coins easy to identify later, the Mint moved the mint mark to a new position and made it much larger. That decision is what makes war nickels easy to spot today.
How to Spot a Silver War Nickel
The Large Mint Mark Above Monticello
Turn the nickel over. On a silver war nickel, a large P, D or S sits directly above the dome of Monticello on the reverse.
- P = Philadelphia
- D = Denver
- S = San Francisco
The “P” was a first. Before 1942, Philadelphia coins carried no mint mark at all. On regular Jefferson nickels from before and after the war, the mint mark is small and sits to the right of Monticello, or on the obverse from 1968 onward.
The Tricky 1942 Nickels
The composition changed partway through 1942, so 1942 is the one year where you need to look carefully:
- 1942 with no mint mark: copper-nickel, not silver
- 1942-D with a small D to the right of Monticello: copper-nickel, not silver
- 1942-P with a large P above Monticello: silver
- 1942-S with a large S above Monticello: silver
All regular-issue Jefferson nickels dated 1943, 1944 and 1945 are silver and should show the large mint mark above the dome.
What Doesn’t Work: Weight, Magnet and Color
- Weight: a war nickel weighs the same 5.00 grams as a regular nickel, so a scale won’t tell them apart.
- Magnet: neither type is attracted to an ordinary magnet, so that won’t help either.
- Color: the manganese in the alloy often gives war nickels a darker, grayish or brownish toning. Worn regular nickels can look dark too, though, so color is only a hint.
The mint mark is the reliable check.
All 11 Silver War Nickel Issues
A complete set of circulation-strike silver war nickels has 11 date and mint combinations:
| Year | Philadelphia (P) | Denver (D) | San Francisco (S) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1942 | 1942-P | (not silver) | 1942-S |
| 1943 | 1943-P | 1943-D | 1943-S |
| 1944 | 1944-P | 1944-D | 1944-S |
| 1945 | 1945-P | 1945-D | 1945-S |
Most of these were struck in the tens or hundreds of millions, which is why worn examples are common and inexpensive. The 1943-D has the lowest mintage of the regular issues, at a little over 15 million.
Silver Content and Melt Value
To estimate melt value, multiply the silver weight by the spot price of silver:
Melt value per coin ≈ 0.05626 × silver spot price (per troy oz)
Because war nickels are a small denomination, they hold a lot of silver relative to face value. Twenty war nickels ($1 face value) contain about 1.125 troy ounces of silver. A standard roll of 40 ($2 face value) contains about 2.25 troy ounces.
| Quantity | Silver content | At $30/oz | At $50/oz | At $70/oz |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 war nickel | 0.05626 oz | $1.69 | $2.81 | $3.94 |
| $1 face value (20 coins) | 1.125 oz | $33.76 | $56.26 | $78.76 |
| 1 roll (40 coins, $2 face) | 2.25 oz | $67.51 | $112.52 | $157.53 |
These figures use the as-struck silver weight. Heavily worn coins contain slightly less. Silver prices change every day, so plug in the current spot price for a live figure. Our junk silver value guide compares war nickels with 90% and 40% coins by face value.
Which War Nickels Are Worth More Than Melt
Most circulated war nickels trade close to their silver value. A few are worth noticeably more.
Key Dates and Varieties
- 1943-D: the lowest mintage of the series. It still isn’t rare, but nice examples carry a premium.
- 1943/2-P overdate: traces of a “2” are visible under the “3” in the date. This is a well-known variety and can be worth far more than melt, depending on condition.
- Doubled-die varieties: several exist for 1943, 1944 and 1945, and they’re best confirmed with a loupe and a variety reference.
Full Steps and High Grades
On Jefferson nickels, collectors look closely at the steps at the base of Monticello. Many war nickels were weakly struck, so coins with complete, sharply defined steps are scarce. Grading services may label them Full Steps, and high-grade Full Steps examples can sell at substantial premiums over typical uncirculated coins.
Proofs
The Mint struck proof Jefferson nickels in 1942 in both compositions: a copper-nickel version with no mint mark, and a silver 1942-P with the large mint mark. The silver proof had a small mintage of roughly 27,600. No proof nickels were made for collectors in 1943 to 1945.
Watch Out for the 1944 No-Mint-Mark Nickel
All genuine 1944 nickels were struck in the silver alloy and carry a large P, D or S above Monticello. A 1944 nickel with no mint mark is a sign of a counterfeit. Counterfeiter Francis LeRoy Henning produced fake nickels in the 1950s, and his 1944-dated fakes famously lack the mint mark. They’re made of copper-nickel and contain no silver. Today they’re a collectible curiosity, but they aren’t silver war nickels. For general methods of spotting fakes, see our guide to testing for fake silver coins.
Selling or Buying War Nickels
- Sort before you sell. Check for 1943/2-P overdates, sharp Full Steps and uncirculated coins before selling a batch by weight.
- Ask how they’re priced. Dealers often quote war nickels separately from 90% silver, either per coin or per dollar of face value. The spread over or under melt can differ from 90% coins.
- Know what’s in a “junk silver” lot. Some sellers include war nickels and 40% halves alongside 90% coins, which changes the total silver content.
War nickels appeal to some silver buyers because they’re small, divisible and easy to identify. They also don’t circulate today, so you’re unlikely to find many in pocket change.
After the War
The Mint returned to the standard 75% copper, 25% nickel alloy in 1946, and the mint mark went back to its small position to the right of Monticello. No circulating US nickel has contained silver since. The other short-lived US partial-silver coin, the 40% Kennedy half of 1965-1970, is covered in our article on 40% silver Kennedy halves. Every US silver denomination is listed in our guide to silver in pre-1964 US coins.