The short answer: 1913
The most valuable year for US nickels is 1913. That year produced the 1913 Liberty Head nickel, one of the most famous rarities in American coinage. Only five are known, and examples have sold for millions of dollars, with reported sales above $4 million.
1913 also has the first-year Buffalo nickels, in Type 1 and Type 2 versions. The 1913-S Type 2 Buffalo is a key date in that series. Most other 1913 Buffalo nickels are affordable.
The 1913 Liberty Head nickel story
The Liberty Head (“V”) nickel was replaced by the Buffalo nickel in 1913. No Liberty Head nickels were officially struck that year. Yet in 1920, five 1913-dated Liberty Head nickels appeared. A former Mint employee, Samuel Brown, displayed them, and it’s widely believed they were struck unofficially at the Philadelphia Mint.
All five are accounted for today, and two are in museum collections. Because they so rarely come up for sale, each sale makes news. They’re as much a legend as a coin, and no one will find one in a jar of old nickels.
The most valuable nickels by series
Values below are rough guides from published price guides and reported sales. They depend heavily on grade.
Shield nickels (1866–1883)
The first US five-cent coins made of copper-nickel.
- 1867 With Rays. Rays between the stars on the reverse were removed early in 1867, so the With Rays version is much scarcer. It brings more in every grade.
- 1877 and 1878. Struck only as proofs, in small numbers. They’re valuable even when impaired.
- 1880. A very low business-strike mintage makes this the key date. Worn examples sell for hundreds or more, and uncirculated business strikes are very rare.
- 1879/8 and 1883/2 overdates. Popular varieties that carry premiums.
Liberty Head nickels (1883–1913)
- 1913. Five known, as described above.
- 1885 and 1886. The key business-strike dates. Worn examples sell for hundreds of dollars.
- 1912-S. The last and scarcest branch-mint Liberty nickel. Worn examples sell for well over $100.
- 1883 “No CENTS”. The first 1883 nickels had only a V for the denomination, and some were gold-plated and passed off as $5 gold pieces. Common, but popular.
Buffalo nickels (1913–1938)
- 1918/7-D overdate. A 7 is visible under the 8 in the date. Thousands in circulated grades and six figures in high uncirculated grades.
- 1916 doubled die obverse. Thousands even when worn. See the 1916 Buffalo nickel value guide.
- 1937-D “3-Legged.” Over-polishing removed one of the bison’s front legs. Hundreds in low grades, thousands uncirculated.
- 1913-S Type 2, 1921-S, 1924-S and 1926-S. Low-mintage key dates that are expensive in better grades. The 1926-S is especially rare in uncirculated condition.
- 1936-D “3½-Legged” and 1935 doubled die reverse. Additional varieties with premiums.
Jefferson nickels (1938–present)
- 1939-D and 1950-D. Lower-mintage dates. The 1950-D had the lowest mintage of the regular series and was widely hoarded, so it’s available but carries a premium.
- 1942–1945 war nickels. Made with 35% silver to save nickel for the war effort. Identify them by the large mint mark (P, D or S) above Monticello’s dome on the reverse. Each contains about 0.0563 troy ounce of silver.
- 1943/2-P overdate and 1939 doubled Monticello reverse. Varieties with premiums. See our doubled die coins list.
- Full Steps. For Jefferson nickels, grading services may note “Full Steps” when the steps of Monticello are fully struck. Some otherwise common dates are very scarce with Full Steps and sell for hundreds or more in top grades.
Nickels you might actually find
Most valuable nickels are auction-level rarities. These are the ones worth looking for in old rolls, jars and inherited coins:
- Silver war nickels (1942–1945). Worth at least their silver value. Look for the large mint mark above Monticello.
- Buffalo nickels with full dates. Even common dates bring a little more than face value. Check every one for a D or S below FIVE CENTS and for the 1937-D 3-Legged.
- 1939-D and 1950-D Jeffersons. Modest premiums in circulated grades, more uncirculated.
- Liberty Head and Shield nickels. Any of these is worth more than face. Check for the key dates listed above.
How to check a nickel’s value
- Identify the type and date. On Buffalo nickels, a worn date sharply lowers the value.
- Find the mint mark. Use our mint mark location guide.
- Look for varieties with a magnifier: overdates, doubled dies and missing legs.
- Estimate the grade honestly, and check recent sold prices.
- Get key dates authenticated. The 1913-S, 1918/7-D, 1937-D 3-Legged and 1950-D have all been faked or altered.
For other denominations, see the old US coins value chart.