US Coin Values

Indian Head Penny Value Chart (1859-1909): Key Dates and Grades

Indian Head penny value chart for 1859-1909: the 1877, 1909-S and 1864-L key dates, semi-keys and varieties, common dates, and how to grade by LIBERTY.

On this page
  1. Indian Head pennies at a glance
  2. Indian Head penny value chart: key dates
  3. Semi-key dates and varieties
  4. Common dates
  5. The three main types
  6. How to grade an Indian Head penny
  7. Where’s the mint mark?
  8. Spotting fakes and altered dates
  9. Tips for collecting Indian Head pennies

Indian Head pennies at a glance

The Indian Head cent was struck from 1859 to 1909. It was designed by James B. Longacre and shows Liberty wearing a feathered headdress. It’s one of the most popular 19th-century US series. Common dates are inexpensive, and a handful of key dates give the series its challenge.

  • Common dates from the 1880s to 1909 often sell for a few dollars in worn condition.
  • Key dates like the 1877 and 1909-S sell for hundreds or more even when worn.
  • Condition matters a lot. Uncirculated coins with original red color are worth many times more than brown, worn examples.

Values below are rough guides drawn from published price guides and reported sales. Check a current guide from PCGS, NGC or Greysheet for exact figures.

Indian Head penny value chart: key dates

Coin Mintage Circulated (Good–Fine) Uncirculated (MS60–MS63, brown or red-brown)
1877 852,500 Roughly $700–$1,500 Several thousand dollars and up
1909-S 309,000 Roughly $400–$700 Roughly $1,000 and up
1869 About 6.4 million Roughly $50–$250 Several hundred dollars and up
1872 About 4.0 million Roughly $50–$300 Several hundred dollars and up
1871 About 3.9 million Roughly $40–$200 Several hundred dollars and up
1864-L (bronze, with L) Part of the 1864 bronze mintage Roughly $50–$200 Several hundred dollars and up
1908-S About 1.1 million Roughly $80–$150 Roughly $250 and up

The 1877 is the key date of the series. It’s widely counterfeited and altered, so buy it certified.

The 1909-S has the lowest mintage of any Indian cent. It was struck in the final year, just before the Lincoln cent replaced it.

Semi-key dates and varieties

Coin What to look for Rough premium
1859 First year; laurel wreath reverse with no shield Tens of dollars worn; hundreds uncirculated
1860–1864 copper-nickel Lighter color than bronze; thicker coin Tens of dollars worn
1866–1868 and 1870 Lower-mintage bronze dates Tens of dollars and up worn
1869/9 A doubled 9 in the date Hundreds and up
1873 doubled LIBERTY Clear doubling on LIBERTY Hundreds to thousands
1873 Open 3 and Closed 3 The shape of the 3 in the date Modest difference; Closed 3 slightly scarcer
1886 Type 1 and Type 2 Position of the last feather relative to the C and A in AMERICA Type 2 brings more
1888/7 A 7 under the final 8 Thousands

On the 1886 Type 1, the lowest feather points between the I and the C in AMERICA. On Type 2 it points between the C and the A. Type 2 coins are scarcer, especially in better grades.

Common dates

Date range Typical worn value Typical uncirculated value
1879–1909 (common dates) About $2–$5 Tens of dollars; more for red coins
1874–1876, 1878 Roughly $10–$40 Hundreds

The 1880s, 1890s and 1900s produced tens of millions of cents a year. Those dates are easy to find in worn condition, which makes them a good starting point for a collection.

The three main types

  1. Copper-nickel, laurel wreath (1859). The reverse shows ONE CENT in a laurel wreath with no shield. These coins are thicker and lighter in color than later cents. They weigh about 4.67 grams.
  2. Copper-nickel, oak wreath with shield (1860–1864). The reverse has an oak wreath with a small shield at the top.
  3. Bronze (1864–1909). The Mint switched to a thinner, lighter bronze coin (about 3.11 grams) in 1864. Later that year, Longacre’s initial “L” was added to the ribbon behind Liberty’s neck. The 1864 bronze with L is scarcer than the version without it.

How to grade an Indian Head penny

The quickest test is the word LIBERTY on the headband:

What you see Approximate grade
No letters of LIBERTY Good
Parts of a few letters Very Good
All letters visible but worn Fine
All letters sharp, and the diamond pattern on the ribbon clear Extremely Fine or better
No wear on the hair, feathers or cheek; original luster Uncirculated

The feather tips and the hair near the ear are other good spots to check for wear. On uncirculated coins, color matters: RD (red), RB (red-brown) and BN (brown) coins sell at very different prices.

Where’s the mint mark?

Almost all Indian Head cents were struck in Philadelphia and have no mint mark. The only exceptions are the 1908-S and 1909-S. Their S mint mark is on the reverse, below the wreath and just above the rim. See our mint mark location guide for every US coin.

Spotting fakes and altered dates

  • 1877: look out for altered 1875 or 1879 dates. Check the shape of the last digit and compare with an authenticated image.
  • 1908-S and 1909-S: the S may be added to a common Philadelphia coin. A genuine S has a consistent shape, and its position and size match reference photos.
  • 1888/7 and 1869/9: wear and damage can mimic an overdate. Compare carefully.
  • Any coin priced well below market is a warning sign.

For key dates, buy coins certified by PCGS, NGC or ANACS. If you’re selling one, certification usually pays for itself.

Tips for collecting Indian Head pennies

  • Start with the common 1880s–1900s dates to learn grading, then add semi-keys.
  • Buy the 1877 and 1909-S certified.
  • Prefer original, uncleaned coins. Cleaned coins look unnaturally bright or pinkish and sell at a discount.
  • Store them in inert holders or albums away from humidity. Copper reacts easily.

When you’re ready to move on, the rare wheat pennies value chart covers the Lincoln cents that followed. The most valuable pennies list ranks the top cents across all eras.

The complete guide to us coin values

Old US Coins Value Chart: Which American Coins Are Worth Money
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →