1916 Buffalo nickel value at a glance
Most 1916 Buffalo nickels are worth a few dollars to a few hundred, depending on the mint mark and condition. The exception is the 1916 doubled die obverse, a rare variety that can sell for thousands even in low grades.
| Coin | Mintage | Circulated (Good–VF) | Uncirculated |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1916 (Philadelphia, no mint mark) | About 63.5 million | About $2–$25 | Roughly $50–$400 in MS60–MS65; more in top grades |
| 1916-D | About 13.3 million | Roughly $15–$100 | Roughly $150 and up |
| 1916-S | About 11.9 million | Roughly $10–$100 | Roughly $150 and up |
| 1916 doubled die obverse | Very rare | Thousands of dollars | Six figures for the finest |
| 1916 matte proof | About 600 struck | Not applicable | Roughly $1,500 and up |
These are rough ranges drawn from published price guides and recent sales of certified coins, such as PriceCharting’s records for PCGS, NGC and ANACS slabs. Raw (ungraded) worn coins usually sell for less than certified ones. Values change, so check a current guide before you buy or sell.
Find the mint mark first
Turn the coin over. On Buffalo nickels the mint mark is on the reverse, below the words FIVE CENTS, at the bottom edge under the bison’s mound.
- No letter: Philadelphia
- D: Denver
- S: San Francisco
The mint mark is small and can be weak on worn coins, so use a magnifier. For other coins, see our guide to US mint mark locations.
1916 (Philadelphia), 1916-D and 1916-S compared
1916 (no mint mark). Philadelphia struck over 63 million, so this is a common date. Worn examples with a full date are inexpensive. The premiums are for uncirculated coins with full detail, and the price rises steeply at MS65 and above.
1916-D and 1916-S. Each branch mint struck around 12–13 million, about a fifth of Philadelphia’s output. Both are scarcer in every grade and sell for more, especially in Fine and better. Many Denver and San Francisco Buffalo nickels from this period were struck softly, so sharply struck uncirculated examples get extra premiums.
The 1916 doubled die obverse
The 1916 doubled die obverse is one of the most valuable Buffalo nickel varieties. The obverse die was made with a doubled image, so the coins show clear doubling, most visible on the date. Some doubling also shows on the Native American’s profile and nearby details.
- It’s often reported to have gone unrecognized for decades after striking.
- Very few are known, and most are well worn.
- Even low-grade examples sell for thousands. PriceCharting’s records include a PCGS F-12 that sold for about $10,500 in 2023. Uncirculated examples are extremely rare and have reportedly sold for six figures.
How to check: look at the date with a 5x to 10x magnifier. On a genuine doubled die, the doubling looks like a second, offset set of raised digits with rounded edges. Flat, shelf-like doubling is machine doubling. It’s common and adds no value. Our doubled die coins guide explains the difference. Any 1916 that looks doubled should be authenticated by PCGS or NGC.
Other 1916 varieties: No F and Two Feathers
Two minor varieties are known from Philadelphia:
- No F. The designer James Earle Fraser’s initial “F” normally sits below the date. On some 1916 nickels it’s missing because the die was heavily polished.
- Two Feathers. The headdress normally shows three feathers. On this variety, die polishing removed one, leaving two.
Both carry modest premiums over a regular 1916. Sales records show certified examples in VG to Fine often bringing tens of dollars, and more in higher grades. Wear can also hide the F or a feather, so these are best confirmed by an expert or a grading service.
1916 matte proofs
Philadelphia struck about 600 proof Buffalo nickels in 1916 with a matte (sandblast-like) finish for collectors. They’re scarce and sought after, and they typically sell for $1,500 and up depending on grade. Some worn or cleaned business strikes are mistaken for proofs. A genuine matte proof has a distinctive granular surface and sharp, squared rims.
How to grade a 1916 Buffalo nickel
Buffalo nickels wear quickly because the date and design high points stand above the surface. Check these spots:
- The date. A full, sharp date is the first sign of a better coin. A partially worn date lowers the grade.
- The bison’s horn. On a well-preserved coin, the full horn is visible to the tip. On worn coins, the horn is flat or partly missing.
- The braid and hair. Detail in the hair above the braid and in the braid itself shows how much wear the obverse has.
- The bison’s head and shoulder. These are the first places to flatten on the reverse.
- Luster. Uncirculated coins show original mint luster that swirls as you tilt the coin.
A rough guide: a coin with a full horn, a sharp date and clear braid detail is likely Very Fine or better. A coin with a readable date but no horn is likely Good to Very Good.
Worn or missing dates
Many Buffalo nickels have dates worn so thin they’re hard to read, or gone completely. Dateless Buffalo nickels have very little collector value.
Some people use acid (“date restorers”) to bring back a faint date. This etches the metal and leaves a visibly damaged patch. It can reveal whether a coin is a key date, but the coin’s value stays low. Collectors and grading services will treat it as damaged.
Is a 1946 nickel related?
People who search for a 1916 nickel sometimes ask about the 1946 nickel too. The 1946 is a Jefferson nickel, not a Buffalo nickel, and it’s a common date. The mint mark is on the reverse, to the right of Monticello. Most 1946 nickels are worth face value or a little more. The premiums are for high-grade uncirculated coins, especially those with fully struck steps on Monticello, and for genuine mint errors. For the rarest nickels of all, read what year is the most valuable US nickel.
Selling or buying a 1916 nickel
- For a worn 1916 P, grading fees usually exceed the coin’s value. Sell it with other Buffalo nickels or keep it in a collection.
- For a 1916-D or 1916-S in Fine or better, or any uncirculated 1916, compare recent sold prices before you sell.
- For a possible doubled die, have it certified first. A genuine certified example sells for far more than an uncertified one, and certification protects the buyer against fakes.
- Never clean the coin. Cleaning lowers the value of any Buffalo nickel.
For a wider view of which old US coins are worth money, see the old US coins value chart.