US Dollar Coins

1878 Morgan Dollar: 8 Tail Feathers vs 7 Tail Feathers and Their Values

How to tell an 1878 Morgan dollar with 8 tail feathers from 7, the 7/8 overpunched variety, the two 7TF reverses, which mints struck each and relative values.

On this page
  1. The Short Answer
  2. Why the 1878 Morgan Has Two Feather Counts
  3. How to Count the Tail Feathers
  4. The Main 1878 Varieties
  5. Which Mints Struck Which
  6. Values: How the Varieties Compare
  7. Grading and Prooflike Surfaces
  8. Watch for Fakes
  9. Building an 1878 Variety Set

The Short Answer

The first Morgan dollars, struck at Philadelphia in early 1878, show an eagle with eight tail feathers. Within weeks the Mint changed the design to seven tail feathers, and every later Morgan has seven.

Before new dies were ready, some existing 8-feather dies were re-impressed with the 7-feather design, creating the 7/8 tail feather variety, where traces of extra feathers show under the seven.

In general:

  • The 8 tail feather (8TF) coin carries a premium over a common 7TF Philadelphia coin.
  • The stronger 7/8TF varieties are usually worth more again.
  • The 7TF coins come in two reverse styles. The 1878-CC and 1878-S always have seven feathers.

Why the 1878 Morgan Has Two Feather Counts

George T. Morgan’s original reverse showed an eagle with eight tail feathers. After production began, Mint officials decided the design should be changed. The reason most often given is that real eagles have an odd number of tail feathers. Morgan revised the hub to show seven.

Philadelphia needed dollars fast to meet the requirements of the Bland-Allison Act, which mandated large monthly purchases of silver for coinage. So rather than waiting for all-new dies, the Mint pressed the new 7-feather design into some of the existing 8-feather dies. The result was a die showing seven bold feathers with the tips of the old ones still visible underneath.

The Mint also made a further reverse change in 1878, which created two distinct 7TF reverse styles.

How to Count the Tail Feathers

  1. Turn the coin to the reverse, the eagle side.
  2. Find the tail, the fan of long feathers below the eagle’s body, between the arrows and olive branch the eagle holds.
  3. Count the long feathers from left to right. Use a 5x or 10x loupe and good light.
  4. Look between and below the feathers for extra feather tips. If you see seven main feathers with partial feathers poking out beneath, you likely have a 7/8TF.

Wear can make the count harder, since the tail is a fairly high point. On well-worn coins, rely on the overall shape and the date and mint mark, and get a second opinion if needed.

The Main 1878 Varieties

8 Tail Feathers

The original design, struck only at Philadelphia early in 1878. It has no mint mark, and the eagle has eight clear tail feathers. About 750,000 were struck, according to commonly cited figures. That’s far fewer than the 7TF Philadelphia coins, which is why the 8TF carries a premium.

7/8 Tail Feathers

Seven tail feathers struck over eight, from re-impressed dies. Collectors catalog several die varieties, often called “strong” and “weak” depending on how many and how clearly the underlying feathers show. Strong examples, where three to five extra feather tips are easy to see, are the most sought after.

7 Tail Feathers, Reverse of 1878

The first 7TF reverse. The eagle’s breast is fairly flat, and the top arrow feather is parallel to the arrow shafts. Collectors often call this the “Parallel Arrow Feather” (PAF) reverse.

7 Tail Feathers, Reverse of 1879

A revised 7TF reverse introduced late in 1878 and used in later years. The eagle’s breast is rounder (more convex), and the top arrow feather is slanted. Collectors sometimes call this the “Slanted Arrow Feather” (SAF) reverse.

To tell the two 7TF reverses apart, compare the top feather of the arrows with the arrow shafts beneath it. Parallel means Reverse of 1878. Angled means Reverse of 1879.

Which Mints Struck Which

Variety Philadelphia Carson City (CC) San Francisco (S)
8 Tail Feathers Yes No No
7/8 Tail Feathers Yes No No
7 TF, Reverse of 1878 Yes Yes Yes
7 TF, Reverse of 1879 Yes No No

The branch mints began striking Morgans after the switch to seven feathers, so 1878-CC and 1878-S coins always show seven. The 1878-CC is a popular first-year Carson City coin, and the 1878-S was struck in large numbers.

Values: How the Varieties Compare

Values for all 1878 Morgans depend heavily on grade, strike and surface quality, and the silver price sets a floor. In relative terms:

  • 1878 7TF (Philadelphia), either reverse: The base coin. Common in circulated grades and widely available in lower Mint State. Collectors may pay a little more for the less common of the two reverses in a given grade.
  • 1878 8TF: Typically priced above a 7TF Philadelphia coin in the same grade, and the gap widens in higher Mint State grades.
  • 1878 7/8TF: Usually more than the 8TF, especially for strong varieties in uncirculated condition. Weaker varieties with only faint traces sell for less.
  • 1878-CC: Priced above the 1878-S and the 7TF Philadelphia coin, because of its lower mintage and Carson City appeal. Many survived in the GSA hoard. See our guide to GSA Carson City Morgan dollars.
  • 1878-S: Generally among the more affordable 1878 coins in Mint State.

Proofs were struck at Philadelphia with both eight and seven tail feathers. They’re scarce and sell for much more than business strikes.

For current prices, check recent auction results for the exact variety and grade. Make sure the variety is attributed on the holder if you’re paying a variety premium.

Grading and Prooflike Surfaces

Early 1878 coins were often struck from fresh dies, and many show prooflike (PL) or deep mirror prooflike (DMPL) fields, with reflective, mirror-like surfaces around frosted designs. Certified PL and DMPL examples of 8TF and 7/8TF coins are popular and carry extra premiums.

When grading an 1878 Morgan, look at:

  • Liberty’s cheek and the hair above the ear for wear and bag marks.
  • The eagle’s breast feathers, which are a high point on the reverse.
  • The luster: original, unbroken luster versus the dull or overly bright look of a cleaned coin.

Watch for Fakes

Counterfeit Morgans exist for many dates, including first-year 1878 coins, and some have been offered with fake variety features. Check that the coin:

  • Weighs about 26.73 g and measures 38.1 mm.
  • Isn’t attracted to a magnet.
  • Has sharp, natural-looking details with no grainy or cast-looking surfaces.

For a coin sold at a variety premium, buy certified examples with the variety attributed by a major grading service.

Building an 1878 Variety Set

The 1878 issues make a compact, interesting set:

  1. 1878 8 Tail Feathers
  2. 1878 7/8 Tail Feathers (strong)
  3. 1878 7 Tail Feathers, Reverse of 1878
  4. 1878 7 Tail Feathers, Reverse of 1879
  5. 1878-CC
  6. 1878-S

Collecting them side by side makes the design changes easy to see, and it’s a good introduction to Morgan die varieties. For more on die varieties and building a wider set, see our guide to building a Morgan silver dollar collection. For other famous Morgan dates, see rare $1 coins to look out for.

The complete guide to us dollar coins

Rare $1 Coins to Look Out For: From the 1804 Dollar to Presidential Dollars
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →