US Dollar Coins

Why is it illegal to own a 1964 Peace dollar?

Why a genuine 1964-D Peace dollar is illegal to own: the 1965 strike, the silver shortage, the melt order, government-property rules and how to spot fakes.

On this page
  1. The Short Answer
  2. What Was the 1964-D Peace Dollar?
  3. Why Coins Struck in 1965 Are Dated 1964
  4. Why the Coins Were Melted
  5. Why Owning a Genuine One Would Be Illegal
  6. Did Any Survive?
  7. Is the 1964 Peace Dollar You Found Real?
  8. What to Do if You Think You Have One
  9. Modern Peace Dollars Are Perfectly Legal

The Short Answer

A genuine 1964-D Peace dollar would be illegal to own because the coins were never issued. The Denver Mint struck them in May 1965. Within days the government stopped production and ordered every piece melted. Since none were ever released into circulation or sold, the Treasury’s position is that any example that escaped the melting pot was taken without authorization and remains government property. If one surfaced, it could be seized.

No genuine 1964-D Peace dollar is publicly known to exist. Nearly every “1964 Peace dollar” you’ll see is a replica or a privately made fantasy piece. Owning those is generally legal.

What Was the 1964-D Peace Dollar?

The Peace dollar was struck from 1921 to 1928 and in 1934 and 1935. In 1964 Congress authorized a new run of silver dollars, partly because of demand from casinos in the West and pressure from silver-producing states. The Mint chose to revive the Peace dollar design.

In May 1965 the Denver Mint struck about 316,000 of the new coins, with a 1964 date and a D mint mark.

Why Coins Struck in 1965 Are Dated 1964

At the time, the US was dealing with a severe coin shortage, and the Mint had legal authority to keep using the 1964 date on coins struck later. This “date freeze” was meant to discourage collectors and speculators from hoarding coins of a new date. So although the Peace dollars were made in 1965, they carried the 1964 date.

Why the Coins Were Melted

By the mid-1960s, rising silver prices meant the silver in US coins was close to, or worth more than, face value. The public was already hoarding silver coins. Critics argued that new silver dollars would be pulled straight out of circulation and wouldn’t help the coin shortage at all.

Production was halted almost as soon as it started, and the Treasury announced that the coins would not be released. The Mint reported that all the struck pieces were melted. Shortly afterward, the Coinage Act of 1965 removed silver from dimes and quarters, reduced the silver in half dollars, and barred the minting of silver dollars for five years.

Why Owning a Genuine One Would Be Illegal

The legal reasoning rests on a simple point: the coins were never monetized. A coin becomes lawful money, and lawful private property, when the government issues it. Since the 1964-D Peace dollars were never issued, any survivor would have left the Mint without authorization, and the government says it still owns them.

There’s a well-known precedent. The 1933 Saint-Gaudens double eagle, a $20 gold piece, was also struck but never officially released. The government has repeatedly seized examples. In a long-running case involving ten 1933 double eagles found by a Philadelphia family, federal courts ultimately sided with the government, ruling that the coins were never lawfully released and remained government property. Collectors widely expect the same principle to apply to a genuine 1964-D Peace dollar.

The one 1933 double eagle that can be privately owned received a special government release before it was sold at auction. No such release exists for any 1964-D Peace dollar.

Did Any Survive?

Over the years there have been persistent stories that a few pieces left the Mint, for example that some Mint employees were allowed to buy a small number before the recall. None of these stories has been verified with a confirmed, authenticated coin. Major grading services and collector organizations have publicly said they want to examine a genuine example, which shows that none has been confirmed in the open market.

Treat any claim of a surviving coin with caution unless it comes with credible documentation and authentication.

Is the 1964 Peace Dollar You Found Real?

Almost certainly not. The common types are:

  • Replicas and copies: Often base metal, sometimes silver-plated. Replicas made or imported for sale in the US are supposed to be marked “COPY” under the Hobby Protection Act, though many overseas fakes aren’t.
  • Fantasy overstrikes: Some private mints have struck “1964-D” Peace dollar designs over genuine earlier Peace dollars, openly as fantasy pieces. These are genuine 90% silver (from the host coin) but are not US Mint products from 1965.
  • Altered coins: Occasionally a genuine Peace dollar from another year is altered to read 1964.

Quick checks: a genuine 1920s–1930s Peace dollar weighs about 26.73 g, measures 38.1 mm and isn’t magnetic. A cheap 1964 piece that fails any of these is a replica. A piece that passes them is still almost certainly a fantasy overstrike or an altered coin, not a 1965 Denver product.

What to Do if You Think You Have One

  1. Don’t try to sell it as genuine. Selling a replica or fantasy piece as a real 1964-D could be fraud, and if it were genuine, it could be seized.
  2. Look for markings. “COPY” or a private mint’s mark settles the question.
  3. Get an expert opinion from an experienced dealer or a major grading service.
  4. If an expert thinks it may be genuine, get legal advice before doing anything else. A genuine piece would be a federal matter, not an ordinary collectible.

In 2021, for the 100th anniversary of the design, the US Mint revived the Peace dollar as a collector coin in .999 fine silver, and it has issued more since. These are official, lawfully sold coins and completely legal to own, as are all original Peace dollars dated 1921–1935.

For values of an original Peace date, see our 1924 Peace dollar value guide. For the 1921 first year, see 1921 silver dollar values. For more famous dollar rarities and myths, our overview of rare $1 coins to look out for covers the full range.

The complete guide to us dollar coins

Rare $1 Coins to Look Out For: From the 1804 Dollar to Presidential Dollars
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →