US Dollar Coins

Presidential Dollar Errors: Missing Edge Lettering and What It's Worth

What missing edge lettering Presidential dollars are worth, which presidents are known, doubled edge errors, Position A/B and how to spot ground-edge fakes.

On this page
  1. The Short Answer
  2. How Presidential Dollar Edge Lettering Works
  3. Missing Edge Lettering (“Godless”) Dollars
  4. Which Presidents Are Known Without Edge Lettering
  5. What Missing Edge Lettering Dollars Are Worth
  6. Other Edge Errors
  7. Not an Error: Upright vs Inverted Edge Lettering
  8. How to Spot a Fake Missing-Edge Dollar
  9. Searching Rolls for Edge Errors

The Short Answer

A Presidential dollar with missing edge lettering, often called a “Godless dollar”, is a genuine mint error. Most are worth a modest premium, not a fortune. The 2007 George Washington is by far the most common. Uncertified examples typically sell for tens of dollars, and certified gem examples of most presidents have historically been available for under about $100. Scarcer presidents, satin-finish (SMS) coins and top-graded examples can bring several hundred dollars, and the rarest combinations more.

Before you get excited, check two things. The coin should be a Presidential dollar, not a plain-edge Sacagawea, and the edge shouldn’t have been ground off.

How Presidential Dollar Edge Lettering Works

Presidential dollars (2007–2016, with one more in 2020) were the first US circulating coins in a very long time to carry lettering on the edge. The obverse and reverse were struck first. Then the coins went through a separate edge-lettering machine that pressed incused (sunken) inscriptions into the edge.

What’s on the edge depends on the year:

  • 2007–2008: The date, mint mark, IN GOD WE TRUST and E PLURIBUS UNUM, plus 13 stars.
  • 2009 onward: IN GOD WE TRUST moved to the obverse. The edge carries the date, mint mark, E PLURIBUS UNUM and the stars.

So the edge is the only place a Presidential dollar shows its date and mint mark. The dates on the face, such as “1817–1825” on the James Monroe coin, are the president’s term of office.

Missing Edge Lettering (“Godless”) Dollars

If a coin skipped the edge-lettering step, it left the Mint with a plain, smooth edge. On 2007 and 2008 coins that meant no IN GOD WE TRUST anywhere on the coin, and the press dubbed them “Godless dollars”. The publicity, and the motto’s later move to the obverse, made them famous.

There’s another twist. A former Philadelphia Mint police officer was later convicted of stealing large numbers of these error coins from the Mint over several years and selling them to dealers. Those coins are now mixed in with genuine accidental releases, and there’s no way to tell which is which.

Which Presidents Are Known Without Edge Lettering

According to NGC’s research, missing edge lettering coins are known for each of the first 15 Presidential dollars, from Washington through Buchanan. Their reported scarcity varies widely:

  • Most common: 2007 Washington, by a wide margin.
  • Next most common: John Adams, William Henry Harrison, Taylor, Fillmore and Van Buren.
  • Scarcest of the first 15: Jackson and Monroe, with only a few hundred reported of each.
  • Satin finish (SMS) coins: From 2005 to 2010, the Mint’s uncirculated sets used a satin finish. Missing edge lettering coins in that finish are known for several presidents. John Quincy Adams and Madison are the most common, and most others are scarce to rare.
  • 2012 Grover Cleveland (first term): A small number have been reported, far fewer than the early issues.

Reports of additional presidents may appear over time, so check with a major grading service’s current population data before assuming a coin is unknown.

What Missing Edge Lettering Dollars Are Worth

Values depend on the president, finish, grade and whether the coin is certified. As a general guide:

Coin Typical value range
2007 Washington, uncertified, circulated Tens of dollars
2007 Washington, certified MS65 Commonly under about $100
Other common presidents, certified gem Commonly under about $100
Scarcer presidents (Monroe, Jackson), certified Higher, often low hundreds
SMS (satin) finish, certified high grade Hundreds, sometimes more for scarce ones
Top-graded examples (MS67 and up) Can reach several hundred to over $1,000

These are broad ranges. Error coin prices go up and down with collector interest, and the scarcity of the Monroe and Jackson coins hasn’t always been reflected in their prices. Check recent auction results for the exact president, finish and grade before buying or selling.

Other Edge Errors

Doubled Edge Lettering

Some 2007 John Adams dollars went through the edge-lettering machine twice. There are two kinds:

  • Overlapped: The two sets of lettering run in the same direction and overlap.
  • Inverted: The lettering runs in opposite directions, because the coin went through upside down the second time.

These are popular errors and usually worth more than the common missing-edge Washington. Prices vary with how clear the doubling is and the coin’s grade.

Lettered Blank Planchets

Occasionally a blank planchet received edge lettering but was never struck with the obverse and reverse designs. Lettered blanks from 2007–2008 can be attributed to the Presidential series. From 2009 on, Native American dollars also had edge lettering, so a lettered blank can’t be assigned to one series or the other.

Not an Error: Upright vs Inverted Edge Lettering

Coins went into the edge-lettering machine in random orientations. So on some coins the edge inscription reads upright when the obverse faces you, and on others it reads upside down. Collectors call these “Position A” and “Position B”. Both are normal and neither is an error. Some collectors like to own one of each, but they don’t carry error-level premiums.

How to Spot a Fake Missing-Edge Dollar

A determined person can grind or file off the edge lettering to fake the error. Warning signs:

  • A rounded, scratched or uneven edge. A genuine missing-edge coin has a smooth, flat, uniform edge like an unlettered blank.
  • Low weight. A Presidential dollar should weigh about 8.1 g. Removing edge metal makes it lighter.
  • Reduced diameter. The normal diameter is 26.5 mm. A filed coin may measure slightly less.
  • Copper showing through. Grinding can expose the copper core at the edge, a reddish band where there should be golden brass.

Also make sure it’s actually a Presidential dollar. Sacagawea dollars from 2000 to 2008 were made with plain edges, and that’s normal for them. If the coin shows Sacagawea and her child, the plain edge isn’t an error. See our guide to 2000-P Sacagawea dollar values for the varieties that do matter on those coins.

For any missing-edge coin you plan to sell, certification by a major grading service confirms it’s genuine and identifies the president and finish.

Searching Rolls for Edge Errors

Many collectors still look for these errors by searching dollar coin rolls from banks or the Mint:

  • Roll the coins on a flat surface or fan them out so you can see the edges quickly.
  • Look for a plain edge on any coin with a president’s portrait.
  • Look for doubled or jumbled lettering, especially on 2007 John Adams dollars.
  • Check the date range. Missing edge errors are concentrated among the 2007–2009 issues, plus a few later coins.

Circulation production of Presidential dollars stopped at the end of 2011, after large stockpiles built up at the Federal Reserve. Coins from 2012 onward were made only for collectors, so they rarely turn up in ordinary change.

For more on Presidential dollars, including the James Monroe coin that confuses many owners with its “1817–1825” dates, see our overview of rare $1 coins to look out for.

The complete guide to us dollar coins

Rare $1 Coins to Look Out For: From the 1804 Dollar to Presidential Dollars
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →