US Dollar Coins

US Trade Dollar Values (1873-1885) and How to Spot Chopmarks and Fakes

What US trade dollars are worth, which dates and mints exist, key dates like 1878-CC, how chopmarks affect value and how to spot the many fakes.

On this page
  1. The Short Answer
  2. Why the Trade Dollar Was Made
  3. Trade Dollar Specifications
  4. Which Dates and Mints Exist
  5. What Trade Dollars Are Worth
  6. Type I and Type II Designs
  7. Chopmarks: What They Are and How They Affect Value
  8. How to Spot a Fake Trade Dollar
  9. Legal Tender Status
  10. Selling a Trade Dollar

The Short Answer

Genuine US trade dollars are 90% silver coins struck from 1873 to 1885. Even common dates in worn condition sell well above their silver value. Prices climb with grade and scarcity:

  • Common dates in circulated grades: A solid premium over melt.
  • Uncirculated examples: Considerably more.
  • Scarcer dates such as the 1878-CC: A large premium.
  • Proof-only years (1879–1885): Expensive, and the 1884 and 1885 are major rarities.

The most important point is that trade dollars are among the most counterfeited US coins. Before you think about value, confirm the coin is real.

Why the Trade Dollar Was Made

In the 1870s, US merchants trading in China and elsewhere in Asia competed with the Mexican silver peso, which was widely trusted there. Congress created the trade dollar in 1873 to give American traders a coin with slightly more silver than the standard dollar. It was meant mainly for export, not domestic use.

The coin didn’t work out as planned. As silver prices fell, trade dollars flowed back into the US and circulated below face value. Their legal tender status was revoked in 1876, business strikes ended after 1878, and an 1887 law let holders redeem trade dollars, many of which were then melted.

Trade Dollar Specifications

Detail Specification
Years 1873–1885 (business strikes 1873–1878, proofs only 1879–1885)
Designer William Barber
Composition 90% silver, 10% copper
Weight 420 grains (about 27.22 g)
Diameter 38.1 mm
Pure silver About 0.7874 troy oz
Mints Philadelphia (no mark), Carson City (CC), San Francisco (S)
Mint mark location Reverse, below the eagle and above “DOL” of DOLLAR

The obverse shows Liberty seated on bales of merchandise, facing left toward the sea and holding an olive branch. The reverse has an eagle and the inscriptions “TRADE DOLLAR” and “420 GRAINS, 900 FINE”. The weight inscription is a handy identifier.

Which Dates and Mints Exist

Year Philadelphia Carson City San Francisco
1873 Yes Yes Yes
1874 Yes Yes Yes
1875 Yes Yes Yes
1876 Yes Yes Yes
1877 Yes Yes Yes
1878 Proof only Yes Yes
1879–1883 Proof only None None
1884 Proof only (about 10 known) None None
1885 Proof only (about 5 known) None None

This table is one of the quickest fake detectors. A trade dollar dated 1879 or later with a CC or S mint mark doesn’t exist as a genuine coin. A worn “1880 trade dollar” with no mint mark should also be treated with great suspicion, since 1879–1885 coins were struck only as proofs.

What Trade Dollars Are Worth

Trade dollar values depend on authenticity, date, mint, grade, chopmarks and surface quality. Exact prices move with the silver market and collector demand, so use recent auction results for your specific coin.

Common Dates

The 1874-S, 1875-S, 1876-S, 1877 and 1877-S are among the more available dates. In circulated grades they carry a solid premium over their silver content. In uncirculated grades they’re worth considerably more, and gems are scarce.

Scarcer Business Strikes

  • 1878-CC: The key business strike. Relatively few were struck and many were later melted, so it carries a large premium in every grade.
  • Other Carson City dates: Several, such as the 1873-CC and 1876-CC, are scarcer than the San Francisco coins, especially in higher grades.
  • 1875 (Philadelphia): Lower mintage than many other dates and generally sells for more.

Proofs, Including 1884 and 1885

Philadelphia struck proof trade dollars for collectors through 1883. These are scarce but can be collected by date. The 1884 and 1885 trade dollars, roughly ten and five known respectively, were made outside official records and only came to light years later. They rank among the great US rarities and have sold for high six- to seven-figure sums.

Type I and Type II Designs

The design was modified in 1876, so you’ll see two obverse and two reverse types:

  • Obverse Type I: The ends of the ribbon behind Liberty’s head point to the left.
  • Obverse Type II: The ribbon ends point downward.
  • Reverse Type I: A berry sits beneath the eagle’s left talon (on the viewer’s right).
  • Reverse Type II: No berry under the talon, and the eagle’s details are slightly redesigned.

Coins from 1876 and 1877 come in combinations of these types, and certain pairings are scarcer than others. Collectors interested in varieties track them separately, and some combinations carry a premium.

Chopmarks: What They Are and How They Affect Value

In China, merchants and money changers often punched small characters, called chopmarks, into silver coins to show they’d tested the metal and found it good. Many trade dollars that circulated in Asia carry one or more chops.

How chops affect value:

  • For most collectors, a chopmarked coin is worth less than an unchopped coin of the same date and grade, because the chop is damage to the original surface.
  • For collectors who specialize in chops, they’re part of the coin’s history. Coins with clear, attractive or unusual chops, or many chops, can carry their own premium.
  • Heavily chopped coins, with chops that distort the design or crack the coin, generally sell for less than lightly chopped ones.

Certification services can note chopmarks on the holder.

There’s a catch: fake chopmarks exist, and some are added to counterfeit coins to make them look more authentic. A chopmark doesn’t prove a coin is genuine.

How to Spot a Fake Trade Dollar

Counterfeits, many produced in China, are widely sold online, sometimes in large quantities and at prices that seem reasonable. Use these checks:

  1. Check the date and mint. Compare against the table above. Impossible combinations are fakes.
  2. Weigh it. A genuine trade dollar weighs about 27.22 g. Many fakes are noticeably light.
  3. Measure it. It should be 38.1 mm in diameter.
  4. Try a magnet. Silver isn’t magnetic. Some fakes are steel-based.
  5. Look at the details. Fakes often have mushy stars, weak lettering, an odd-looking Liberty face, or grainy, pitted fields from casting.
  6. Check the edge. A genuine trade dollar has a reeded edge with even, crisp reeding. Look for seams or irregular reeding.
  7. Be wary of uncirculated-looking “rare” dates at modest prices.

Even a coin with the right weight and metal can be a high-quality counterfeit. For any trade dollar worth more than a modest amount, buy certified coins from major grading services, or have the coin authenticated before you sell.

Congress removed the trade dollar’s legal tender status in 1876. The Coinage Act of 1965 restored it, so trade dollars are technically legal tender again, at a face value of one dollar. Their collector and silver value are, of course, far higher.

Selling a Trade Dollar

  • Get it authenticated first if there’s any doubt, especially for a key date or uncirculated coin.
  • Don’t clean it. Cleaning is common on trade dollars and greatly reduces value.
  • Get several offers. Dealers who specialize in 19th-century US coins tend to value trade dollars more accurately than general buyers.
  • Use auction for key dates, proofs and high-grade certified coins.

For other silver dollars with a long history of counterfeiting, see how to tell if an 1804 silver dollar is real. For where trade dollars fit among the great US dollar rarities, see rare $1 coins to look out for.

The complete guide to us dollar coins

Rare $1 Coins to Look Out For: From the 1804 Dollar to Presidential Dollars
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →